Skip to main content
← All episodes
Repeat Purchase

Black Friday Sales Strategy Part 2

· Hosted by Brooks Bostick & Corey Reid

Run your sale too long and shoppers wait. Make it too complicated and they leave. In Part 2, Brooks and Corey Reid, on/Sight’s Chief Growth Officer, explain how to plan a Black Friday and Cyber Monday sale that’s short, simple and urgent.

In this episode

  • When to start: why the strongest window runs from the Monday of Thanksgiving week through Cyber Monday, and why extending a sale past that can look desperate
  • Change the offer each day: feature a different product or collection every day so you have something new to email about and shoppers keep coming back
  • Keep the offer simple: if it takes two paragraphs to explain, shoppers won’t understand it, and complicated tiered discounts are hard to set up
  • No midnight launches: schedule your sale ahead of time instead of having your team switch it on at midnight on Thanksgiving
  • Don’t advertise a discount almost nothing qualifies for: an “up to 70% off” email with one item at 70% off costs you shoppers’ trust
  • Set a revenue goal and work backward: use your conversion rate and average order value to see what you need to hit it
  • Choosing a discount: start with your gross margin, don’t count on holiday buyers coming back next year, and test percent-off against dollars-off in your emails now

If you missed Part 1, start there. It covers the product page, simplicity tests and compare-at pricing.

Questions or a topic you’d like us to cover? Email us at hello@on-sight.co.

Repeat Purchase is a podcast by on/Sight about growing ecommerce brands, with practical episodes for Shopify merchants.

Full transcript

Read the full transcript

Brooks Bostick 00:32
All right, first things first. I said every episode would be 15 minutes, and I know I talked about this last time, but Black Friday, Cyber Monday and this whole sales period are so important to us that we split the longer episode we recorded in two. Please enjoy part two of Black Friday Sales Strategy from Repeat Purchase.

Corey Reid 00:58
When should people start running sales?

Brooks Bostick 01:00
When should people start running sales? Macy's would say October 15th. Traditionally, the big retailers and department stores start Black Friday early. I think I saw Black Friday deals over the summer this year. I'd say condense it as much as you can. I also want to talk about sequencing sales, because that's really important, and we have a number of clients who've done it really successfully over the years.

The earliest I'd start a sale is probably the week before Black Friday week. It's usually a little easier to get people's attention then, and inboxes aren't as full of other deals. This changes every year, and sales do keep starting earlier, but the week before is usually a decent tactic. I wouldn't necessarily launch your full sale then, although some of our clients do. I'd focus on a pre-sale, or at least start getting your messaging in front of customers. Think about how much our phones explode with Black Friday sales once we get into that week. The messaging is really in your face. Ad costs go up. Your inbox explodes. Even on Thanksgiving Day, it's constant. Somebody is always talking about Black Friday.

So you can start messaging as early as you want, but I'd start discounting the week before Black Friday at the earliest and carry it through at least Cyber Monday. Once you get past Cyber Monday and keep extending your sale, you start to look a little desperate. That week is the core. If we narrow it down even further, starting your sale on the Monday of Thanksgiving week and ending it the following Monday, Cyber Monday, is a great tactic. It also creates urgency. Otherwise customers see your messaging the week before Black Friday and think, "They have a sale, and it'll run for a while, so I'll buy later," and you've lost that customer. If you keep them in a short window, create urgency around the sale and get them to buy within it, you've done your job.

Corey Reid 03:13
I agree. You have to start before Black Friday, or you'll get lost in the inbox. One thing I want to hear you talk about, Brooks: tiered discounts for Black Friday and Cyber Monday.

Brooks Bostick 03:29
As in tiered spending?

Corey Reid 03:30
Yes. I've run a lot of sales during this time of year, and there's always a tendency to make the discount tiers as complicated as possible. Spend this, get this. Spend more, get more. Spend even more, get even more. My message to everyone running a sale is: make sure you can explain what the sale is. If it takes more than two paragraphs, your customers won't understand it. That happens constantly. We want to put these things on sale. Maybe not those things. We want to give a bigger discount if people spend more. It gets so complicated to explain that customers don't even understand what the sale is. That's my biggest pet peeve this time of year. A group of marketers gets together and says, "We should run this. What if we do this? What if we do that?" and you end up with a word soup of sale messaging that's extremely hard to communicate and hard to set up, because you're trying to do so many different things. So one big thing I'd look at now, in October, is what your sale is going to be and how you'll actually pull it off, so you don't get to the week before and realize you need custom functions or some random setting you have to turn on and off. It gets extremely complicated and doesn't make much sense.

One last thing
save yourself the pain. You don't have to launch your sale at midnight. It can go live the day before. It can go live quietly. You can schedule your Klaviyo emails and other messaging to send on their own. Please don't make your ecommerce managers wake up at midnight to turn on a sale. It doesn't help customers anymore. Nobody stays up that late to shop like they're at the mall in the 1990s.

Brooks Bostick 05:33
So no digital doorbusters, huh?

Corey Reid 05:35
You can have a digital doorbuster, but schedule it. There are rollouts and plenty of other options. Just don't center all your marketing on "the sale goes live at midnight" and then have someone turning on the Black Friday sale on Thanksgiving night. That's a lot of work for, I promise you, not much impact.

Brooks Bostick 05:57
What it plays into, though, is the sense of urgency we get from sales. That's why doorbusters and the old iPhone launches worked so well. People waited outside. They felt urgency. They had to get the product. You can play into that without launching at midnight. You can build it over the course of a week.

One thing I want to touch on is sale sequencing, which I've seen work really well for clients big and small: running different sales on different days. We think of Black Friday as a sales period, but what you do day to day can change. You can offer deeper discounts on certain collections. You can launch a new collection during Black Friday. It doesn't have to be the same thing every day. Switching it up creates urgency, and I think you'll get repeat buyers too. "Everything is 30% off the whole time" is a fine strategy, and a lot of brands are really successful with it, but switching it up gives you more to talk about all week.

Here's what I've seen brands adopt over the past couple of years. Say we start our sale the Monday before Thanksgiving and run it through Cyber Monday. Every day, or every other day, depending on your catalog, you discount certain products or categories. The discount itself might not change, but you're on a marketing calendar with a set cadence in Klaviyo, SMS or wherever you talk to your customers, so you have a different sale to promote each day. That's been really effective, and it doesn't make anything complicated for the customer. Different products might be on sale tomorrow, that's all. I also love that it brings people back to your site several days in a row. Say you run one sale with a beautiful countdown timer. I actually love countdown timers, and that's probably its own episode someday. But if that timer is counting down seven days, someone landing on your site won't feel any urgency. If your sale runs a week and you feature something different every day, you have something new to talk about for seven days in a row, and a reason for customers to come back seven days in a row. I'd argue that sale will be more effective, because you get to talk to your customers every day and give them something new to shop.

Corey Reid 08:35
Totally. Two things based on what you said. First, it's incredibly nerdy that you said out loud, "I love countdown timers." You're a real nerd. You win.

Brooks Bostick 08:44
Thank you. I think they're lovely.

Corey Reid 08:47
Second, I'd stay away from the classic "up to 70% off," where you go into the catalog and there's one half-eaten piece of bread that's 70% off. Just don't do that. Shoppers are smarter than that, and it's disingenuous. When you run a brand, your customers give you a certain amount of trust. Don't throw that away for one day just so you can say "up to 70% off." I see why people do it: you want people to open the email and click through. But if they go looking for that 70%-off item and it's the half-eaten piece of bread, they'll just roll their eyes. Protect your brand better than that, and be honest about what you're offering.

Brooks Bostick 09:45
I agree. I love that. Don't lure people in with a big discount they can't find, or one on a product they don't want. Keep it simple. The overall theme we keep coming back to is simplifying for the holidays. We're recording this in October, and it'll come out in October. Our clients usually start planning this in July and August, but even now, if you're a smaller brand, there's time to set up an effective sale. Just make it simple. Simple works here, because you're competing with all the other noise and with competitors in your space. Keeping it simple lets customers come in, find exactly what they need and buy, and then you've made that sale.

Corey Reid 10:37
I feel compelled to bring up one more thing, Brooks: set a goal. It sounds funny to say out loud, but set a goal. How much revenue are you trying to drive during that period? What's your normal average order value? How many sessions would you need, at that average order value and your conversion rate, to hit the goal? Work your numbers backward so you know whether you can hit it and what you need to do. How many emails do you need to send? What click-through rate do you need on your ads? You can go into Black Friday, Cyber Monday and Q4 in general feeling confident instead of thinking, "I hope this works." There's always a little of that. Ad costs are high and inboxes are busy, so there's always some "I hope this works" going into Q4. But do everything you can to feel confident in your plan. Even if the plan feels like a stretch, at least you'll know you have everything you need to hit it.

Brooks Bostick 11:45
Here's a hot take. Well, it's more of a question, but I'll set it up as a hot take. You've run P&Ls for a lot of ecommerce businesses over the years. What's the best discount?

Corey Reid 11:58
The best discount? Well, there are two parts to that.

Brooks Bostick 12:02
90%? 80%? 70%?

Corey Reid 12:06
Don't think that way. First, understand your P&L. What's your gross margin, and how much can you give? I get a little nervous when a brand wants to discount really heavily, especially if it doesn't have the healthiest gross margin. We often see that Q4 customers don't come back at a high rate the following year, so don't tell yourself a story like, "Our CAC to LTV ratio is going to look great." Run a discount that makes sense for your brand. If you want to stay around break-even, that's fine. But don't tell yourself you'll win a ton of customers who'll buy from you forever. A Q4 buyer might just be a Q4 buyer, or a sale buyer.

Second, once you know what you can offer, is it $50 off or 50% off? I'd go with whichever number looks bigger, whatever comes across as more savings. If you're offering 10% off a $1,000 item, say $100 off, not 10%. For me, it comes down to your gross margin, your average order value and what will get people to your site. You can go back and forth on this for a long time. This is also a great thing to test now. Run a simple sale to prime the pump, get more people into your funnel and opening your emails, and see whether percent-off or dollars-off gets the higher click-through rate. That will most likely tell you which kind of ad, email or discount to run.

Brooks Bostick 13:55
So the testing could happen in Klaviyo. You could test open rates for a percentage versus a dollar amount on a small item or a one-off flash sale.

Corey Reid 14:07
Yeah, I'd send several emails with different subject lines, one with percent off and one with dollars off, and see which gets the higher open rate. Your subject line sells the open, and your content sells the click and gets someone to your site. There are a few ways to test it, but we're just looking for a read on what brings interested buyers to the site. It's a psychology lesson. You need as many signals as you can get to land Q4 well.

Brooks Bostick 14:37
Yep, I couldn't agree more. October is the time to start, and the time to test. That makes a ton of sense.

And that wraps up Black Friday and Cyber Monday for Repeat Purchase. If you have any questions, we'd love to chat. That doesn't mean we have to work together, but if you have a perspective to share or want us to dig into anything, please reach out. Every merchant needs to focus on this, and it's a really important time of year to do it. You can email us at hello@on-sight.co. Thanks for listening to Repeat Purchase, and we'll see you next time.

Let’s Talk

Whether you've got a project in mind, a wild idea, or just want to talk shop—we're always up for a good convo. Drop us a note and let's see what we can build and grow together.