Skip to main content
← All episodes
Repeat Purchase

Black Friday Sales Strategy Part 1

· Hosted by Brooks Bostick & Corey Reid

Black Friday isn’t one day anymore. It’s closer to two full weeks of November, and the brands that do best start getting ready in October.

In this episode, Brooks is joined by Corey Reid, Chief Growth Officer at on/Sight, for his first episode as co-host. Before on/Sight, Corey scaled DTC brands like East Fork Pottery, Hedley & Bennett and Counter Culture Coffee. Together they cover how to set up your Shopify store to turn more of your Q4 traffic into sales.

In this episode

  • Two kinds of holiday shoppers: people treating themselves to deals, and people buying gifts, and how to sell to both
  • Why you shouldn’t rebuild your site for the holidays: change too much at once and you can’t tell what’s working
  • Optimizing the buy panel: clear offers in the announcement bar, navigation that points people to gifts, and strike-through pricing so shoppers can see the deal
  • Simplicity tests: why showing fewer variants can help shoppers coming from ads decide faster, and how to test it with landing pages in October
  • Discount codes vs. compare-at pricing: why Corey is “100% team change your prices,” and tools that make sitewide price changes easier

Part 2 covers when to run your sale, which discount types to offer, how to create urgency, and when to stop making changes to your site.

Repeat Purchase is a podcast by on/Sight about growing ecommerce brands, with practical episodes for Shopify merchants.

Full transcript

Read the full transcript

Brooks Bostick 00:31
All right. Welcome, Corey. Good to have you here.

Corey Reid 00:33
What's up, dude? How are you?

Brooks Bostick 00:35
I'm good. Welcome to your first episode of Repeat Purchase, and thank you for being my co-host.

Corey Reid 00:41
Honestly, this is a dream. I'm very excited to channel my inner Ira Glass. Some hard-hitting journalism is about to happen. That's what we're doing, right?

Brooks Bostick 00:57
Yes. So should we dive right into politics, or where do you want to start? Actually, let's start with an intro. Who are you?

Corey Reid 01:02
Perfect. My name's Corey Reid, and I'm the Chief Growth Officer here at on/Sight. I have the nice distinction of being a former on/Sight client who's now an employee, which is really cool. Before on/Sight, I worked with direct-to-consumer brands, helping them scale. Some of the brands I've worked with are East Fork Pottery out of Asheville, North Carolina, where I live now; Hedley & Bennett out of LA, which sells some really cool aprons; and Counter Culture Coffee, where I led marketing and ecommerce. Then I found my way to on/Sight to work with you, Brooks.

Brooks Bostick 01:43
Well, I'm very grateful to have you. You're working on growth for most of our brands, and growth in Q4 is a little different from growth the rest of the year. Q4 is very much about Black Friday and Cyber Monday, which is exactly what we're here to talk about today. Let's start by framing up why Black Friday matters for brands, why doing it right is important, and why starting a bit earlier than you might expect will set you up for success in what I'd now call the two core weeks of November. Ten years ago it was a lot different. People sold for a day or two. Now brands are selling the week before Black Friday and the week after, with extended sales. Sales strategy has turned November into an entire sales month.

So it's very important for our brands, and for anybody selling anything online. Whether you have a seasonal product or not, this is the time of year to sell. Some of those customers will be core customers coming back for a repeat purchase, and some will be new, so we have to cater to both audiences, and they're different in a lot of ways. So, Corey, let's talk about why it's important. How is Black Friday going to impact the bottom line for a lot of our brands?

Corey Reid 02:58
For consumer brands, we've seen that people are simply more likely and more willing to spend in Q4. What's more interesting, from an empathy point of view, is that when we get into Black Friday and Cyber Monday, which honestly needs a rebrand because it's an entire month now, there are really two types of shoppers. The first is the person buying for themselves. Think about what you do the week before Thanksgiving and the days after. I find I'm much more often buying for myself. I'm looking for the biggest deals and the things I've been saving up for, because this is the time to buy. That's the mindset we're seeing across all of our clients and the industry in general. The second group is customers looking to buy gifts. So before we even get into what to test before Black Friday and Cyber Monday, it matters because customers are going to spend a lot of money on themselves and a lot on the people they love, and sometimes on the people they don't love. That's why we need to be really thoughtful about the levers we pull and how we space them out to drive as much revenue as we can in Q4.

Brooks Bostick 04:22
One important point about catering to two types of shoppers, or maybe it's more of a question for you: do we need to rewrite the copy on our product pages to support someone who's buying a gift? Does the whole site need to flip over to talk about gifting, instead of what it says the other eleven months of the year, when people are mostly buying for themselves, their partners or their kids?

Corey Reid 04:48
That's a great question. I'd stay away from wholesale changes to the site just because it's a big sales season. You'd be introducing a ton of variables into what could go right or wrong, and I don't trust that. You've been watching your funnel all year. You understand what's working and what isn't, and there's too much risk in deciding everything has to change for Q4. I think that's a silly reason to make a change. Why change what's been working?

Brooks Bostick 05:21
So instead of making wholesale changes for the holidays, we're doing what we already do, slightly better.

Corey Reid 05:28
Yeah, but Brooks, what does "better" mean to you?

Brooks Bostick 05:31
That's a great question. When I define better, I think of better data and better performance on the site: converting more customers in a way that's really impactful for Q4. Converting customers takes a lot of forms. It starts with speaking to them properly. Again, I don't think that means turning the whole site into a giant gifting experience, but it does mean speaking to them in a way that lets them make a quick purchase and get everything they need. I'm thinking a lot about the top of the product page, which we call the buy panel internally, and optimizing it so the sale is visible. At the end of the day, we're trying to get as many people as possible through the product page, into the cart and into checkout. So I'd focus on what these customers need, how to give them exactly that, and how to get them to buy as quickly as possible. Less time on site, and more instant reactions to a discount, a sale or a compelling holiday product.

Corey Reid 06:37
What you just called out is really interesting, because you said we want to optimize the buy panel. If we're optimizing the buy panel for this season, I'd go even higher, starting with your navigation and your announcement bar. If you're running an offer, how do you make sure it's clear on every page? Then make your navigation very clear about which product is right for which person. That's where you might want to merchandise differently. Merchandise your navigation so every customer who lands on your site understands, "This is a place with very giftable products," or, "This is the right product for you." Getting the right person to the right product at the right time is really important.

Then, as we scroll down to the product page and the buy panel, there are a few things I want to make sure we have going into Q4. If we're running a sale, make sure we take credit for it. What was the original price? What's the strike-through price? We need to show all of that. We want image and video carousels that do a lot of storytelling. One thing we've seen in a bunch of heat maps is that people swipe like crazy on product pages, so how do you pack a lot of information in there? That's a very important piece of real estate. Then, further down the buy panel, if you've got multiple variants, one thing I'd test before Black Friday and Cyber Monday is whether it helps to show all of them, or whether we should limit them to cut down on decision paralysis. If someone goes from an ad for a specific product to its product page during the holidays, the message should really be, "Go buy that product." So when we talk about optimizing your product page, find a few areas that make it easier for shoppers to know which product is right for them and to trust that it will meet their needs.

Brooks Bostick 08:34
So as we test ideas around that in October, we're looking for simplification more than anything, from a UX standpoint. Giving customers fewer choices here lets them buy faster. That's what you're getting at.

Corey Reid 08:48
In my career, I've run a lot of what we call simplicity tests. Sometimes you want to cross-merchandise a ton of products in your buy panel, because you might not get a customer to the right product directly and they'll want to keep shopping around. But I really believe Q4 is about closing the sale and getting the right person to the right product. Also, with how brands will be running Meta ads in Q4, a lot of traffic will come from ads. So when someone sees an ad for a product they love and clicks through to it, they shouldn't have to wonder whether it's the right one for them. That's one area I'd optimize: new, product-driven traffic from ads. Do we send it to a product page with lots of variants to choose from? Or do we pull those variants back and give shoppers fewer decisions, knowing some might bounce, but that we may see less bouncing around the site?

Brooks Bostick 09:48
That's a great point. For brands that have the resources, I'd go a step further and test simplified product pages in landing page software, where you can really simplify the experience and create better continuity from that qualified click. If somebody clicks one of your ads, either it's a really engaging ad or they're interested in the product, so if they click through to your site, I'd consider them qualified. A landing page tool lets you spin up a test quickly, get a read, and then decide how to structure your product page once November arrives. That's easy for most brands, since those tools are easy to find. It lets you simplify where you can: pull out a single variant of a product, create continuity from the ad click all the way to purchase, and give you and your team a way to judge how well it works. As you said, simplification is really key.

One other thing you mentioned that I want to touch on is discounting, and compare-at pricing. There are two schools of thought on Black Friday discounts. One is adjusting your prices, so your current retail price becomes the compare-at price, and you give the product, say, a 20% discount. The other is a sitewide discount code that customers enter at checkout. What's your perspective, and what have you seen work best for Black Friday over the years?

Corey Reid 11:26
Great question. Honestly, I hate discount codes. As a consumer, they're a pain. I hate having to type one in and make sure I got it right. As a merchant, I hated them even more, because with a discount code you often don't give the customer the satisfaction of seeing that they're getting a deal. What I want to show very clearly is, "You're getting a deal. This product used to cost $300, and now it's $200." That creates urgency, because the strike-through price might go away. Some sites can turn on settings that show discounted prices while using discount codes, but I'd say 95% of Shopify stores won't have that. So whenever I'm offering a discount, I'm thinking about how to take credit for it and show it, so customers understand this is a great deal they need to grab now. That also covers both use cases: someone buying for themselves and someone buying a gift.

So I'm 100% team change your prices and use a compare-at price. If the accounting side has to do a little work to true up the numbers at the end of the year, so be it. You'll see much more impact than you would from a discount code in your announcement bar that people have to remember to use, because they don't get the satisfaction of seeing how much they're saving on the collection page or the product page.

Brooks Bostick 12:54
It's harder to merchandise a discount code, too. There's a lot of manual work to put it on the collection page and in your announcement bar. People are used to seeing prices. Most shoppers know where to look for a price, whether that's the collection page or the product page, and if that price is discounted, they'll react better and get through to checkout. It's also worth noting that entering a discount code at checkout can be cumbersome, especially on mobile. Then you're relying on someone clicking a link, and running a sale and getting people the discount they came for gets a lot more complicated. Do the work to discount your products and show the compare-at price. Depending on how many SKUs you have, you can use tools like Matrixify or Shopify's bulk editor, and you can even schedule imports and exports so it happens automatically. There's a tool for just about any major price change across your site.

And with that, we've broken our first rule of Repeat Purchase, which is that episodes are no longer than 15 minutes. We obviously have a lot to talk about, so I've split this into two episodes. The follow-up on Black Friday and Cyber Monday will cover sale timing, discount types and messaging, creating urgency with customers, and how to plan the rest of October and November to set your business up for success. That includes making sure your whole team is on the same page about discounts, and knowing when to freeze your site and stop making updates, so you have a successful Black Friday.

Thanks for listening to Repeat Purchase. I'm Brooks from on/Sight, and we'll see you next time.

Let’s Talk

Whether you've got a project in mind, a wild idea, or just want to talk shop—we're always up for a good convo. Drop us a note and let's see what we can build and grow together.