What Great Shops Do That Your Website Doesn't
Walk into a great shop and you know right away. The music is good, every corner has its own feel, and the person at the counter tells you what they’ve been loving lately. So why does shopping online feel so flat?
In this unplanned episode, Corey calls Brooks from outside a New York theater after a day at Pop Up Grocer and Big Night. He asks a question every Shopify brand should think about: how do you bring the fun of finding something new in a store to your website?
In this episode
- What great shops do differently: the music, displays that each have their own mood, products set beside each other in ways that make you want to look, and a staff member who tells you what they’d buy as a gift
- Why browsing online feels flat: shelves let you see everything side by side, while most sites keep each product on its own page
- The shop clerk, online: customer service from real people, like Branch Basics’ phone line, and simple video that puts a person on every page
- Your advantage over Amazon: no one ever goes to Amazon for the experience, and that’s where small brands can stand out
- Start with what makes your store feel special, then grow it: what Airbnb’s early photographers teach about starting with what works before worrying about doing it at scale
- Your website is your store: on Shopify you’re not stuck with a retailer’s shelf rules, so try new things, change the experience and make it feel like your own shop
Repeat Purchase is a podcast by on/Sight about growing ecommerce brands, with practical episodes for Shopify merchants.
Full transcript
Read the full transcript
Brooks Bostick 00:00
All right. So this is our first ever impromptu podcast. Corey, where are you right now?
Corey Reid 00:07
I am currently in New York City outside of the public theater waiting to see if I can get a ticket to a show at five o'clock. So this is perfect timing. And I called you because I had some things that I wanted to talk about and I figured might as well just do it on the podcast.
Brooks Bostick 00:23
I love it. And what are you doing in New York City besides waiting for a show? Why are you there in the first place?
Corey Reid 00:30
Yeah. 2027 planning and focusing on like where we need to be going with brands we work with for 2027 is a big part of what I do. And there's no better way to do it than in person with clients. And we happen to have a lot of clients here in New York City. And then on top of that, I'm going to be going to an event for our client Riff, which I'm super excited about, to get to also eat some of Chef Daniel Humm's food that he makes.
Brooks Bostick 00:59
Well, I'm I'm just gonna say I'm very jealous that you get to do that. I'm very, very jealous.
Corey Reid 01:05
You could have came too you could have came too. You really just need to get your priorities straight.
Brooks Bostick 01:09
I know, I know. Having a newborn definitely puts a damper on things. okay, well let's let's jump in and let's yeah, let's hear what you have to say.
Corey Reid 01:18
Yeah, Brooks. So this is this is maybe a little bit more of question for you. and something that I was thinking about today. So I got the great experience of getting to go to a bunch of different stores today that sell CPG goods. specifically two that I have in mind is Pop-Up Grocer and another store, which is near and dear to my heart, which is a store called Big Night, which is also a client. And for both of those stores, I just had the best experience. I was getting to look at all these new brands that were super interesting, getting to, you know, just like stare at packaging, getting to ask people questions about it. So Brooks, that got me thinking, how do we bring that experience online? How do we get the fun, warming your heart feeling of getting to find new brands and experience a brand for the first time online in a much deeper way, like it is personally in person?
Brooks Bostick 02:16
Mm. How do we bridge that gap between the online store and like on shelf discovery? I mean, it's tricky, right? Like on when you go into a retail store, you have the ability to see everything kind of next to each other and it's merchandised completely different. You walk into Whole Foods and there's an experience to be had there, right? on an online store, it's a little bit more siloed, at least traditionally, how traditional e-commerce works. but you still get to show, you know, the packaging and and point. And I to to be completely honest with you, it's a it's a really tough thing to unlock. if you look at you know retailer comps kind of around the e-commerce space, Amazon pretty much has zero energy. They just sell convenience with decent brands. And if your brand happens to have great packaging, it's gonna stand out. But there isn't really much of a a story or there isn't much of like a hook with. With the retailer itself, right? They're just like, hey, come in and buy things from us. yeah, I mean, it that's a really interesting challenge. It's a really interesting challenge and it's a cool thing to think about because you walk into a store and it's immersive, right? How do we make a digital experience that that level of immersive?
Corey Reid 03:26
I mean, and when I walked into Big Night Brooks, something that I was just like taken by was the music was great. There was all of these little vignettes of like the bar area was very moody. And then you go over to the pantry and it's fun and exciting. Then they've got all these like vintage glassware that was just like, those are so beautiful. And then I get to ask the person working there, like, what do you like, what are some of your favorite things these days? And and kind of like showing me, like, I would you know, I got this as a gift for someone. It just made me think too that there's like a personal connection. There's like a personal quality to all of these things. And like it just had me thinking a lot about, you know, all the brands that we work with. There's like really great, amazing people behind them. How do we get the intentionality behind the product that they created or the the brand or the store that they've built? How do we get that to come across? So it just doesn't feel so one note. I think like at the end of the day, one of the things that like really made me like start going deep on this was I, you know, I I I think there's gonna be a world where a lot of these stores and a lot of what we do looks the same because everyone's using pretty similar tooling and like using AI pretty deeply. But there's still this kind of human component to when you walk into a store and you can pick something up. And now I'm not saying that like, okay, well, all of our clients should just go start brick and mortar. That's like their very specific thing. But it did have me like really going deep on how do we just make the online shopping experience feel more personal? How do we make it feel like recommendations to you or actually recommendations, not just okay, we need to get your AOV up, but actually being helpful? And to me, that was like the biggest unlock was that personal touch that I think really can set apart an online experience.
Brooks Bostick 05:10
Well, there's sense of personality to it that I don't think comes out in a lot of different brands. you know, being able, I'll tell you how brands did this a couple of years ago. And I think this is this is actively evolving as we're having this conversation. But a couple of years ago it was all about the founders, right? Like a founder really led the personality of the brand and we would really lean into that on different sites. Fishwife was a really good example. Fishwife used to be very founder forward, now it's very product forward, right? There's still a personality and a story within that. but it's not as much centered around an individual selling you something as it used to be. Now, I think that they're really interesting and cool tools and different ways to get back to that. but the personal touch is really important. You know, I think about it like you think about in terms of a of a retailer, like what kind of leverage do you have? I think customer service is a big piece of this. And it's not like an AI chat, but it is something where it's like you can tell that it's an actual human coming in and saying, hey, you need a recommendation? Do you want help with something? another brand, a longtime client of on/Sight, a brand called Branch Basics, does this by literally having a phone number picked up by humans in Minneapolis. Like it is, and and they talk people through product and through recommendations and through how to clean certain things. And I think that's just really unique. And that, that personality, however you can spin it for your brand, is something that really sets an ecommerce experience apart. Again, comping against a, you know, a retailer like Amazon, good luck ever getting anybody on the phone at Amazon for any particular reason or any even anybody in a chat, right? It's it's it's physically impossible to do so. Small teams have this advantage where you can really lean into customer service, you can really lean into video. And an easy video, you know, even if you don't you're you're not like Big Night and you don't have this beautiful store or you know, mini stores in their case where you can actually go in and film content. You can still record video. You can still have that personal touch throughout your site. And I feel like that really does bridge the gap, right? There's a human here recommending something to me and that feels valuable in most cases. And again, like look around the rest of the e-commerce world. There's not a whole lot of brands actually doing this. A lot of brands have really pulled back their story and pulled back their personality in order to be more performant. But I would argue that performance comes from A really great site, having, you know, great tools in place to then help boost conversion rate and AOV and all of the metrics that we care about. but also having personality, right? And being able to like be approachable by a customer. And a customer goes on there and can enjoy it and talk to somebody. And I think like as we just as you mentioned, as we get deeper into this world of AI and the ease of AI tools, we're gonna start to lose that human connection. And I do think that there is a big Big there's going to be a big emphasis on human connection in the coming years within the digital space.
Corey Reid 08:10
Yeah, I love that. I think like the moral of the story is have a point of view, have a perspective, do some things that are going to speak to people's emotions or their collective memory. Like that is, I think, where a lot of like you you use the word experience a bunch of times, and like There's something about an experience that like is shared by the collective memory of those consumers as opposed to just like the kind of growth hack after growth hack after growth hack after growth hack that ends up happening. And it it it all just becomes very one note. And like it might be in the short term like a way to like kind of boost your meta Roas, but I'm less bullish on that as a way to have an experience online that feels set apart.
Brooks Bostick 08:55
Yep. Yeah. And I think it's an interesting challenge for for small brands, although I think small brands can activate on this much quicker, like I mentioned. The the challenge here is how do you make a large brand personable? Right. Say Big Night had a hundred locations across the United States, which hopefully they will one day. how do you how do you like how do you scale it? Right. And I think that's the the most interesting challenge here is personality is very easy to do when you have a two person marketing team and you're just throwing ideas against the wall and you can Record video and you can be really, really, really responsive on social and you know, use that content on your site. But once you become a really big business, you start to lean more into performance and less into the personal side of things. So, like, I don't know. Do you have any ideas on how you would retain that as a business grows?
Corey Reid 09:45
I part of me, Brooks, just wants to say, like, when it comes to personality and like just trying to figure out like what's the next thing, I think sometimes we're just like a little too focused on scale, honestly. Like screw scale. Excuse my language. Sorry, you can bleep that out. But like I I don't know, I remember like the air I Brooks, do you remember that story about Airbnb when They were first starting off and they just like couldn't figure out how to get the product right. And one of the things they did was like send photographers to apartments in New York City to photograph them. And they started seeing that it worked. And they're like, okay, well, you know, obviously we cannot send a bunch of photographers to all of these different Airbnbs to get them to get rented. But they under they started to understand, like, okay, good pictures means it's more likely to get the Airbnb rented. Like, I I think some of that is with personality, which is like, Don't start with scale, just start with point of view and then figure out how to scale point of view. Like I I think you're right. Like if you said to Catherine over Big Night right now, okay, you have to open a hundred stores, how do you make them feel as great as the three stores you have in New York? She may not know, but just start with like what is great about the three stores in New York that you when you didn't have to think about ultimate scale.
Brooks Bostick 10:55
Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah. So so in this case, don't be afraid of scale. Kind of lean into it. Lean into the parts that are unique about your business. And then just like ride those through as long as you can. And I would almost I would almost bet doing that will help you scale in the long term because you're gonna start to realize, okay, here are the things that we do as a business that are repeatable and people love in terms of personality, in terms of brand, in terms of our voice, et cetera. and really like taking that. To the next level might just happen naturally, but you never know if you don't take that first step. And I do think we see a lot of brands, especially smaller brands, who are almost afraid of stepping into that because they don't understand how it scales. And really, like you start it and you hang on for dear life because what's gonna end up happening is that it's gonna end up helping you scale. And it might not be this idea, it could be the fifth idea, but you have to start trying and I think that's gonna help everybody evolve and everybody grow long term. I really do.
Corey Reid 11:58
Yeah, I I I love it. It was just I wanted to I wanted to talk through this because there was that feeling of wow, this is a really special shopping experience. And I I couldn't, you know, you think through talking about it, it's having a point of view, having personality, caring about what is what is, you know, what is on the radio and like how, you know, how are we merchandising? And it to me, I just like I want to see more of that online. I think there's I don't think it has to be okay, well, only physical locations can do that. I think everyone can have a store that feels uniquely them. And when the customer comes there, they understand, okay, I get what this brand's trying to sell me and I get why they matter a lot less than, my gosh, the ad hook was amazing and I got to the landing page and it had all the benefits that I needed. Which is like those things are important, don't get me wrong. But sometimes it's just okay to have a little fun and be cool in yourself.
Brooks Bostick 12:53
Mm-hmm. Yeah. Yeah. And and what an advantage we have in the D2C world and within Shopify, because we can literally do whatever we want. Like there are no confines and there's less confines literally by the day at this point. You go sell your product literally anywhere else in any other retail, and you are playing by somebody else's rules, right? Which limits what you can ultimately do. It if you have a platform where you have ultimate freedom. Like you would on social media, just lean in, right? It doesn't hurt to do that. And you can always test it and you can always pull it back. But because you have that advantage, it's just another thing that you can do and test and really help your brand evolve. And yes, it is that experience. It's being able to, to, to walk in here, like your, you know, your your storefront, in this case, your your direct-to-consumer store, and and show the customer something different, It shows you care. It shows that you're not just like everybody else and that there's a sense of sense of brand and personality, even if you're selling other people's products. So I absolutely love that. And I think this is like this is such a cool way of of articulating it and really showing people and mainly just encouraging people to step in and and get a little weird and try something different. And They'll probably end up coming back with something they never knew about themselves or their brand. And that's evolution, that's scale long term. I I really agree with that.
Corey Reid 14:18
appreciate you jumping on for this emergency podcast I I was, you know, I got ten minutes to find out if I get these tickets at the public theater. But I just it was burning through my brain and I just wanted to talk through it.
Brooks Bostick 14:30
Yeah, I love it. Well, good luck with your tickets. good luck for the rest of your time in New York City. And again, I am so, so jealous. Please do not tell me how good Daniel's food is. I don't want to hear it.
Corey Reid 14:41
Honestly, dude, the big the big takeaway is everyone just needs to go shop at Big Night because I was, it was, it was just the most fun experience being in that store.
Brooks Bostick 14:49
If you're ever in New York City, look up.