Skip to main content
← All episodes
Repeat Purchase

How To Give Customers More Than They Expect

· Hosted by Brooks Bostick & Corey Reid

Why do customers come back? Often it's because a brand gave them more than they expected. Brooks and Corey dig into Unreasonable Hospitality by Will Guidara and what it teaches Shopify brands about retention.

Brooks has bought Will Guidara’s book for his team, most new hires and most on/Sight clients. In this episode he makes the case that it’s really a masterclass in retention. Corey and Brooks share real examples, from handwritten notes on shipping boxes to flowers nobody asked for, of the small things that turn first orders into lifelong customers.

In this episode

  • Hospitality as a retention strategy: why giving customers more than they expect builds the strongest connection a brand can have, and the link between Eleven Madison Park, Chef Daniel Humm and Riff (eatriff.com)
  • Handwritten notes at The Feed: how Brooks, as employee number two at a Boulder sports nutrition retailer, set the business apart from Amazon with notes on the box, and why customers posted them on Instagram
  • Answering the phone: how Branch Basics puts its team in front of customers instead of an AI chatbot, and why that keeps retention so high
  • The $30 bouquet: the Zappos story Corey has told dozens of people, and why small moments of care can be some of the most efficient customer acquisition you’ll ever buy
  • Free two-day shipping for preemie parents: how Little Sleepies met an unexpected moment for its customers, and the response from its VIP community
  • Use the touch points you already have: packing your own orders, customer service, personalization; you don’t need a big team to do a little extra
  • This week’s takeaway: pick ten first-time orders and send each one a handwritten thank-you card

Repeat Purchase is a podcast by on/Sight about growing ecommerce brands, with practical episodes for Shopify merchants.

Full transcript

Read the full transcript

Brooks Bostick 00:00
Welcome to Repeat Purchase. Before we start, the fine print.

Corey Reid 00:04
Results may vary. Your conversion rate is your own. Past performance of a Shopify store is not indicative of future revenue. Side effects of listening may include a longer to-do list.

Brooks Bostick 00:11
And a better night's sleep.

Corey Reid 00:12
I'm Corey, and I lead growth for our clients at on/Sight.

Brooks Bostick 00:16
And I'm Brooks. I run on/Sight, a Shopify agency that works with CPG and direct-to-consumer brands.

Corey Reid 00:21
We spend our days inside stores people love, figuring out what's working, what's broken and what to do next.

Brooks Bostick 00:27
So every episode, we take one ecommerce topic and get through it in fifteen minutes.

Corey Reid 00:31
Site, email, ads, subscriptions, merchandising. Whatever's keeping a founder up at night.

Brooks Bostick 00:37
Now, the name. Yes, we're a little bit obsessed with the second order.

Corey Reid 00:41
Because for a DTC brand, retention is the whole game. Acquiring a customer is expensive, and keeping one is where the business actually gets built.

Brooks Bostick 00:49
But it's also a promise. If we do this right, you'll be back.

Corey Reid 00:53
No slides, no jargon, no forty-minute detour.

Brooks Bostick 00:57
One question, one honest answer, and probably one argument.

Corey Reid 01:02
Probably about subscriptions.

Brooks Bostick 01:04
Yeah, definitely about subscriptions.

Corey Reid 01:06
Well, let's get into it.

Corey Reid 01:09
All right, Brooks, this is a fun one. Most of the time, when someone calls someone to share an idea they're on fire about, it's me calling you in the middle of the workday. But this time you reached out to me, because you're super excited about a concept.

Brooks Bostick 01:28
Yes, indeed. It's all sparked by a book I'm absolutely obsessed with. The book is called Unreasonable Hospitality, written by Will Guidara. I hope I pronounced that right. Sorry, Will. It also has ties to a client of ours, which is really cool. Will was the co-owner of a business, a restaurant, called Eleven Madison Park.

Corey Reid 01:50
It's a little bit of both.

Brooks Bostick 01:53
Restaurants are businesses too. We'll give them that. Eleven Madison Park in New York. Corey, we talked about this a little last time, but what are the ties to our business?

Corey Reid 02:03
Chef Daniel Humm, who is a co-owner of Eleven Madison Park, started a business called Riff, which you can find at eatriff.com, on a beautiful website that on/Sight designed and developed.

Brooks Bostick 02:16
Thanks for the plug. Yes, we did. Every little piece of it, every interaction, every brand moment, done by us. But let's get back to the book. I bought this book for our team two years ago for our annual team summit. I buy it for most of our new hires, and I've bought it for most of our clients at this point. If they had a loyalty program, I'd probably be at the top. I'm expecting to get a commission from this episode. We'll see how that goes.

The concept in general is giving customers more than they expect. You can see how easily that applies to a restaurant. The stories in the book about how they go above and beyond for guests are fantastic. It's a little harder to see how it applies to commerce. But talking through how it applies creates one of the strongest customer connection points you could possibly have, and the better your customer connection, the better your retention. So I could almost reposition this book as a masterclass in how to retain customers.

Let me talk about why it's so important to me, and why I think it's important for businesses as a whole. One of my early ecommerce experiences was at The Feed, a sports nutrition retailer based here in Boulder, Colorado. I was employee number two. What's interesting about a retailer is that you're selling other people's products. You have less of an opportunity to build a brand, and customer connection is trickier because the customer is experiencing a product you didn't make. You just sold it.

So if we talk about unreasonable hospitality, giving more than customers expect, retailers probably have the biggest challenge here. We talked about Amazon last time. Amazon isn't really giving you much besides convenience. The order shows up at your door ten minutes after you place it, and not everybody can compete with that. At The Feed, we were trying to figure out how to set ourselves apart from Amazon. It was the biggest competitor back then, and it still is.

And yes, I was the second employee, so I packed the orders. I was customer service, I was marketing, I did everything. Because I was talking to customers in customer service and also packing their orders, I had a unique relationship with them. In the early days, I knew a lot of the people who were ordering. So I was able to write a note on the packing slip, or often right on the box: "Hey Corey, good luck on your marathon next week." I knew things about customers, so I could take one small step toward connection.

And that went gangbusters. People loved it. They posted pictures of our handwritten notes on Instagram, and it really helped the business grow. Customers weren't expecting it. Getting a package back then, and even today, is a pretty flat experience. Some brands have gone really deep on customer experience and unboxing, and others just put something in a box and ship it. So there's a real advantage to giving customers a little more when you pack your own orders. If you work with a 3PL, that's a lot harder to do, but it's one example of a great touch point.

Another good example of showing up for customers and giving them more than they expect is our client Branch Basics, based in Minneapolis. They've always leaned into customer service as one of their biggest differentiators. Thinking about the customer journey, giving someone more than they expect can be as simple as answering the phone.

I know that sounds so basic. You call United Airlines and you probably get an AI robot half the time. Sorry, guys. But calling an ecommerce brand and having someone pick up and talk it through, "Hey, I lost my order," "Hey, where is my order?", is a unique experience that not many brands offer. A lot of companies put AI chat or some other layer in front of their team. Branch Basics has always done the complete opposite: they put their team in front of everybody. Customers who call in have such a good experience that their retention is through the roof. They know they can email or call that team at any point and get an answer. Ten years ago, I think that would have been an expectation. Now it's something that sets a business apart, and it really embodies this idea of unreasonable hospitality.

Corey Reid 07:15
Yeah, there's so much opportunity there. It's a swerve. Everyone else is going through the AI chatbots or the phone trees, and you get to talk to a real person. It creates a completely different experience. You're swerving away from where everyone else is going, which is interesting almost from a marketing perspective.

Brooks Bostick 07:41
It gets people's attention, too. If you look at other ways to do this, personalization is really cool. Very few ecommerce brands on Shopify have gone deep on personalization, because it's hard to do and it's expensive. But say you have a subscription with a brand like Ritual. You go to their site and you're greeted with, "Hey Corey, welcome back." Those tiny touches throughout the customer experience are what make it unique, and personalization is another great lever.

It depends on which touch points you have. Not everybody can have a customer service team. Not everybody can do personalization. Not everybody packs their own orders. The challenge is to look at what you do have and lean into it as much as you can. If you have a very small team, what customer touch points are available to you, and where can you lean in to create an amazing experience and give someone a little extra? Not a ton extra. I'm not talking about throwing extra product in every order. That's unnecessary, and it'll probably kill your margin. What's the one little thing you can do to make it special, different and unique?

Corey, do you have any examples? Anything you've ordered recently that was over the top, or completely lackluster?

Corey Reid 09:02
Yeah. This is actually an example from almost ten years ago, but it still sticks with me. My grandfather died suddenly of a heart attack. Right before he passed, he had bought some shoes on Zappos. I remember being up in Pittsburgh with my grandma and my family, and one of the things we had to do was return the shoes so my grandma could get the money back.

So we reached out to Zappos. They asked why, and we said that unfortunately he had passed away. The next day, a bouquet of flowers showed up at my grandmother's house with condolences from Zappos. The CX team member had the freedom to do that, and it's a story I tell constantly. It was such a heartwarming thing. I remember my grandma crying and saying, "What the heck?" It's some of the best customer experience I've ever seen.

And I love that I've told this story so many times. Sending those flowers probably cost them, let's call it, $30 back then. They probably had a deal with a flower company. I've told that story to at least 30 or 40 people by now. Think about putting that $30 toward customer acquisition instead. They got some of the most efficient customer acquisition possible, just from me telling that story.

Brooks Bostick 10:34
That's so true.

Corey Reid 10:36
And it still stands out to me as a human-centered brand, one that cared about the moments in their customers' lives, good or bad. That's what sticks with me. Brooks, what about our client Little Sleepies?

Brooks Bostick 10:54
Yeah, that's another really good example. One other example a lot of listeners would know is Chewy. When you cancel a subscription because, say, your dog passed away, they send you flowers or do something kind. Those little touch points make such a big difference and create lifelong customers. Zappos and Chewy are from that same era of commerce.

As for Little Sleepies, this is a new feature on their site. Little Sleepies sells children's pajamas and play clothes, and on the pajama side they have preemie and micro-preemie sizes. If you've had a kid, you know: if you have a preemie or micro-preemie baby, you probably weren't expecting it. Having a child is stressful. The whole birth process is stressful. When you have a very small baby, there's so much that goes into it. You're at the hospital longer. It's very, very stressful.

What Little Sleepies has done, and this is one of the coolest moments I've seen with any of our brands in a long time, is give free two-day shipping on micro-preemie and preemie purchases, acknowledging that you probably didn't expect to have to buy this, so they'll get it to you as fast as they can. To me, that's such an amazing customer moment. They launched it two weeks ago, and last week the Little Sleepies team sent us screenshots from their big VIP Facebook group, where people were talking about it and raving about it. It was such an emotional moment for their customers.

Yes, it sacrifices some margin. But what you get in return is a lifelong customer, because the brand really cares about you and took the time to understand your situation and how best to support you in it. It's truly remarkable. I'd love to see more brands doing Zappos-style and Little Sleepies-style things in the future, because that little bit of extra customer experience goes a long, long way.

And that's really the book at the end of the day. At the restaurant, they research who's coming in for reservations. They look at guests' Instagram to see if they're coming in for a birthday or whatever it might be. If you've watched The Bear, a lot of its interactions with guests, and the fun things they do for them, are based on this book. It provides a little bit of something extra.

And I know some people listening have big teams and some have very small teams, but you can do this regardless of team size. If you're a solo founder doing the marketing and packing the orders, you're probably also talking to customers. So you can lean in and figure out what a customer might need. Doing a little extra and understanding your customer a little better is probably the ultimate retention tool at this point.

Corey Reid 13:52
Yeah, Brooks, that seems like the one takeaway to me. If we want to make this as simple as possible: over the next week, choose ten first-time orders and write each of them a card. A postcard saying thank you. It doesn't even have to go in the box. Just thank them. Ask yourself how you can do a little bit more to show gratitude, or to be unreasonably hospitable to your customers.

Brooks Bostick 14:21
I like that. Well, let's leave it there.

Brooks Bostick 14:24
And that's Repeat Purchase. Subscribe, review, and send us your questions.

Corey Reid 14:29
One question, fifteen minutes, every week.

Brooks Bostick 14:32
And remember, you paid nothing for this.

Corey Reid 14:35
Go get that next win.

Brooks Bostick 14:37
And come back next week. We'll be here.

Let’s Talk

Whether you've got a project in mind, a wild idea, or just want to talk shop—we're always up for a good convo. Drop us a note and let's see what we can build and grow together.