Skip to main content
← All episodes
Repeat Purchase

The Intro

· Hosted by Brooks Bostick

Welcome to Repeat Purchase. After 11 years of running an ecommerce agency, Brooks Bostick has seen just about everything on Shopify.

This first episode sets the stage for what’s to come. If you run a CPG brand, operate an ecommerce business or are just interested in commerce, this show is for you.

Repeat Purchase is a podcast by on/Sight about growing ecommerce brands, with practical episodes for Shopify merchants.

Full transcript

Read the full transcript

Brooks Bostick 00:02
For the last 11 years, we've worked with a certain kind of brand. The coffee you reorder. The pajamas you buy in the next size up as your kids grow. The pantry staple you never let run out. What do they all have in common? Their best customers aren't new. They're the ones who keep coming back. That's the whole idea behind this show. Welcome to Repeat Purchase, a podcast from the team at on/Sight.

I'm Brooks, and I'll be your host week in and week out. Every episode is about 15 minutes and covers one idea for growing your Shopify store: conversion, retention, operations, tech and everything in between. One topic, no filler, and something you can take back to your team the same day. We tell these stories through the lens of CPG brands, because that's where we've spent most of our time, but the lessons apply to pretty much anyone selling anything online.

This first episode is a little different, though. It's just me today. Before we get into tactics, I want to tell you who we are, how we got here and what you can expect if you stick around.

Let me go back to 2015. I started the agency here in Boulder, Colorado, and, funny enough, we didn't start out doing what we do now. We started as a marketing agency. Pretty quickly, we noticed something. We'd run a great campaign, drive a ton of traffic, and then send all those people to a website that wasn't ready for them. We were filling a leaky bucket. So we pivoted into design, development and strategy: fixing the bucket instead of pouring more water into it.

So what do we do now? That's grown into four areas. The first is strategy: figuring out where the growth actually is. Then CRO: testing and research to turn more visitors into buyers. Then design and creative: making the brand feel as good online as it does on the shelf. And then technology and engineering: custom Shopify builds, apps and integrations that make everything run.

The other big shift was realizing that a launch isn't the finish line. We'd launch a beautiful site, the brand would be thrilled, and six months later they'd call and say, "Traffic's up, but we haven't seen much growth." The brands that win are the ones that keep testing and improving long after launch, so that became how we work.

Somewhere along the way, we found our people: CPG brands. Food, beverage, personal care, home goods, the stuff people buy over and over again. A lot of our team has run ecommerce inside CPG companies, so we know what it's like to juggle a DTC site, retail partners, Amazon and a board asking why the numbers look different in every channel. We like to say our job is connecting screen to shelf.

So where are we now? Since 2015, we've designed, built and optimized more than 250 Shopify stores for brands like Fishwife, Little Sleepies, Branch Basics, Omsom, East Fork, Diaspora and a whole bunch more. That's the short version. A lot of stores, and a lot of lessons. Some of them we learned the hard way. Actually, a lot of them we learned the hard way.

The first lesson
a redesign isn't a strategy. For years, brands would come to us and say, "We need a new website." Sometimes they did. But a lot of the time, the site wasn't the problem. It was the offer, or the product page, or the fact that nobody ever came back after their first order. A new coat of paint doesn't fix that. So now, before we design anything, we ask one question: what are we actually trying to change?

The second lesson
discounts buy you a first order, not a customer. It's so tempting to lead with a big welcome offer, and it works, once. But if the only reason somebody bought was the discount, they're probably not coming back at full price. The brands that do this well put that energy into the second order instead: making it easy to reorder, reminding people right around when they'll run out, and giving them a reason to stick around that isn't just a coupon.

The third lesson
more apps don't mean more growth. Every app you add promises a lift, but every one also adds cost, adds weight to your site and adds one more thing that can break. We've audited stores running way more apps than anyone on the team could name. So our rule is pretty simple now: before you add something, figure out what you can take away.

So why does this show exist? Why start a podcast? Because we have the same conversations over and over with clients, prospects and friends running brands. Should we move to Shopify Plus? Is our subscription program actually working? Why is mobile converting so much worse than desktop? Those conversations shouldn't only happen on sales calls, so this show is us having them out loud.

Why call it Repeat Purchase? The name is on purpose. For CPG brands, the repeat purchase is the business model. Nobody builds a lasting food, personal care or apparel brand on one-time buyers. It's also how we think about growth in general. The best results rarely come from one big redesign. They come from small improvements, tested, adjusted and done all over again. That's the loop on our cover art, if you were wondering.

So here's the promise for every episode. One topic: if it's about checkout, it's going to be about checkout. About 15 minutes: short enough for a commute or a coffee break. I think hour-long episodes are great, they're just not for everybody, and I want to keep this tactical and short. Honestly, short is hard. But if we can't get an idea down to under 15 minutes, we probably shouldn't be talking about it in the first place. And something you can use: every episode ends with a takeaway you can bring to your team's next meeting or drop in Slack.

Here's a taste of what's coming. Conversion: product pages, bundles and why your checkout might be quietly costing you sales. Retention: subscriptions, loyalty and getting a first-time buyer to come back. Operations: inventory, fulfillment and all the unglamorous stuff that makes or breaks the customer experience. Tech: apps, integrations and when it's worth building something custom. And omnichannel: how your site fits alongside retail, Amazon, wholesale, TikTok Shop and any other channels you might have.

And maybe more importantly, who are you going to hear from? Starting next episode, I'll be joined by my co-host, Corey Reid, on/Sight's Chief Growth Officer. Corey runs growth for the agency and for every brand we work with. We'll also regularly bring on guests: founders and operators from the brands we work with day in and day out, and sometimes specialists from our own team. The people who've actually been in the room when the numbers don't add up or something breaks.

So who is this podcast for? If you're a founder, an ecommerce manager or part of a team trying to grow a Shopify store without an hour to spare, this is for you. And if you're not in CPG, stick around too. A good product page is a good product page, whether you're selling hot sauce or hiking boots.

So here's your first takeaway, and it's a simple one. This week, pull one number: what percentage of your customers in the last 12 months bought from you a second time? If you don't know that number off the top of your head, that's okay. Most teams don't. But it tells you more about the health of your brand than almost anything else in your dashboard. Write it down, and we'll come back to it.

If you're not sure where to find it, start in Shopify. Go to Analytics, then Reports, and look for your returning customer rate or the customer cohort report. Most stores can get a solid read in a few minutes. Once you have that number, don't stop there. Ask three follow-up questions.

First, how long does it take people to come back? If your product runs out in 30 days but the average second order happens at 90, that gap is money on the table. Second, which products do people buy first when they end up coming back? Those are your gateway products. They should be front and center, not buried on page three of a collection. And third, what actually happens after someone's first order? Walk through it yourself. What emails do they get, and when? Is there anything that makes reordering easier than going back to Google? You don't need to fix all of it this week. Just knowing the answers puts you ahead of most brands.

Next time, Corey joins me and we're talking about Black Friday and Cyber Monday. After all, it's almost Q4. Trust me, this is a good one, and timely. If this sounds useful, hit follow or subscribe wherever you're listening, so the next episode shows up automatically. And if you know somebody running a Shopify store who'd get something out of this, send it their way. That's the best way to help us grow.

Want to talk about your own store? You can find us at on-sight.co. Thanks for listening to the very first episode of Repeat Purchase. I'm Brooks, your host, and we'll see you next time.

Let’s Talk

Whether you've got a project in mind, a wild idea, or just want to talk shop—we're always up for a good convo. Drop us a note and let's see what we can build and grow together.